ComeAllWithin

Rugby => ComeAllWithin Board => Topic started by: DOK on Thursday 03-Jan-2019, 22:53*

Title: This must not be the year when rugby union trashes its finest qualities
Post by: DOK on Thursday 03-Jan-2019, 22:53*
the sport is in danger of throwing it all away (https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2019/jan/02/2019-rugby-world-cup-six-nations-new-year-must-not-trash-qualities-rugby-union)
Title: Re: This must not be the year when rugby union trashes its finest qualities
Post by: Le Tiss on Friday 04-Jan-2019, 07:49*
the sport is in danger of throwing it all away (https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2019/jan/02/2019-rugby-world-cup-six-nations-new-year-must-not-trash-qualities-rugby-union)

Hard to disagree with any of that.
Title: Re: This must not be the year when rugby union trashes its finest qualities
Post by: deadlyfrom5yardsout on Friday 04-Jan-2019, 09:55*
Its a professional sport now with coaches training players on every little edge they can get. The referees maybe need to set their stall out early in the match and come down hard rather than being buddy buddy and looking for "co-operation".
Title: Re: This must not be the year when rugby union trashes its finest qualities
Post by: DOK on Friday 04-Jan-2019, 09:58*
To be fair we are light years away from where discovering opposition fans in our stands would trigger a riot, but I know where he's coming from. When you see Danny Care trying to achieve vertical take off, do you think "good on him for trying to influence the ref" or do you think "leave it Danny, just play the ball"?
Title: Re: This must not be the year when rugby union trashes its finest qualities
Post by: The Absolute Quintet on Friday 04-Jan-2019, 10:33*
Refs have all the sanctions needed. Firmly and consistently applied, these change the game instantly. Whatever happened to the 'rule' that the only player that could speak to the ref was the captain?
Title: Re: This must not be the year when rugby union trashes its finest qualities
Post by: DOK on Friday 04-Jan-2019, 20:50*
I think it gets a bit blurred when refs talk to players. If the ref penalises a scrum, he may say to the prop "your feet were too far back, you slipped, that's why I gave the penalty". At which point the prop responds "You missed the guy opposite pulling me straight to the ground. I couldn't help it" and so an exchange starts up with a player who isn't the captain.