ComeAllWithin

Rugby => ComeAllWithin Board => Topic started by: Neil Quinnock on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 11:58*

Title: James Chisholm
Post by: Neil Quinnock on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 11:58*
Does anyone have an update on James C ? Last time he was seen was at Big Game 11 a month ago. I can't recall if he picked up an injury then or if there's been an update posted elsewhere. I hope it's not a recurrence of his concussion issues.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Quintron on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 13:10*
He’s joined Sale
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Only Joe Quin on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 14:50*
I heard it was Bristol.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Broken Hero on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 17:42*
His brother was an absolute embarrassment today, on several occasions not just Kpoku’s try. Shocking positioning and handling, but his total absence of bravery was unforgivable - not seen its kind since my school days.

My understanding is that a couple of years ago James was digging his heels in a bit over a new contract and essentially Quins had to keep Ross on their books as part of that deal. Can’t imagine Gustard will be doing likewise. Think he needs to be on his way, and soon.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Neil Quinnock on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 17:56*
Errr....no,then ?
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Comet on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 18:00*
Said hello to him after the game. Can't believe he would want to leave. He has been a big part of the improvement this season.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Monte on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 18:02*
Didn’t you ask him if he was injured?
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Broken Hero on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 18:11*
Sorry, wasn’t saying James will leave and no idea if he’s injured. He won’t be going anywhere, could well be club captain from next season. My point was that brother Ross should not be accommodated and indulged any more, and I can’t imagine he will be by Gustard. Hopefully James just being given a breather in these less important games and will be back for the Premiership push.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: raedarius on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 18:25*
Said hello to him after the game. Can't believe he would want to leave. He has been a big part of the improvement this season.

Rumour had it he was in a boot today.  Did you notice whether he was?
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Comet on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 18:42*
No boot. He looked fine. He was on his phone strolling along the front of the North Stand. He will stay and could well be club captain in 2 years.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Quinsgirl84 on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 23:40*
He is injured, unlike the guys going on holiday. He staying put so he could hopefully feature in the Worcester game in a few weeks.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: AJQuin on Saturday 26-Jan-2019, 23:45*
His brother was an absolute embarrassment today, on several occasions not just Kpoku’s try. Shocking positioning and handling, but his total absence of bravery was unforgivable - not seen its kind since my school days.

My understanding is that a couple of years ago James was digging his heels in a bit over a new contract and essentially Quins had to keep Ross on their books as part of that deal. Can’t imagine Gustard will be doing likewise. Think he needs to be on his way, and soon.

Ross didn’t have his best game, but to say he had a total absence of bravery when he threw his body on the line after Robshaw threw what was one of the worst passes this season and it looked to be a certain Sarries try is a bit harsh.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Neil Quinnock on Sunday 27-Jan-2019, 11:39*
A month's rest seems a lot so I hope he's not injured as I think he's been a big part of our improvement this year and with Clifford re-signing, a Dombrandt, Clifford, Chisholm back-row combination for the next few years is quite an exciting prospect.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Mayor West on Sunday 27-Jan-2019, 11:51*
Wasn’t it Ross who chased down and tackled their player who went on to get over the tryline somehow scoring on the second attempt or was it held up or on the third attempt or was he offside to start with. Anyway could have been a try saver.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Only Joe Quin on Sunday 27-Jan-2019, 15:44*
I didn't see the match but when I read the team sheet with Walker and Ibitoye on the wing, I thought Chisholm had been given a tough gig in defence.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Quinten Poulsen on Monday 28-Jan-2019, 00:35*
Wasn’t it Ross who chased down and tackled their player who went on to get over the tryline somehow scoring on the second attempt or was it held up or on the third attempt or was he offside to start with. Anyway could have been a try saver.

He could have brought Kpoku down before the tryline if he'd made a better effort.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: Gone on Monday 28-Jan-2019, 08:22*
He could have brought Kpoku down before the tryline if he'd made a better effort.

Ok maybe, haven't seen it, but he's not troubling our first XV, and we know Walker can't defend -- and all the evidence so far that I've seen shows that Gabs is also currently appalling at it, but has lots of time to sort it out. Not sure it's a big deal frankly.
Title: Re: James Chisholm
Post by: PhilQuin2 on Monday 28-Jan-2019, 10:22*
 I thought Walker had a good game defensively.