News:

  3. TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« previous next »
Pages: 1 ... 9 10 [11] 12   Go Down

Author Topic: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ  (Read 6663 times)

0 Members and 12 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #150 on: »
Quote from: Marsile on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 14:26*

TJ missed it. TMO ignored it.

Well, apart from the TMO telling the ref, who rightly told him that it was too long ago. You can't rule out a try when nothing was wrong with the passage of play that led to the try, but instead with a previous decision. You'd never complete a game.

Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #151 on: »
Quote from: Marsile on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 13:53*

The scenario I described was not a conspiracy. What I described was cheating. You clearly don't understand what conspiracy means.


Whereas you'll have a superb understanding of cheating...
Logged
Funny Funny x 2 View List
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #152 on: »
Quote from: Quinten Poulsen on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 15:52*
It's a common occurance for the ref to check with an assistant on a grounding, and it makes sense as well.

That's exactly my point. He didn't check. The ref declared it held up. The TJ overruled him. Absolutely I'd expect it to go to the tmo, but if the ref thinks it's held up I'd say it's pretty usual to stick with his own infield decision.

Again, the live view was the TJ view. They used the refs view for the tmo replay. Presumably because the live TJ view was inconclusive.
Logged
Agree Agree x 2 Disagree Disagree x 1 View List
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #153 on: »
Quote from: JammyGit on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 16:19*
Well, apart from the TMO telling the ref, who rightly told him that it was too long ago. You can't rule out a try when nothing was wrong with the passage of play that led to the try, but instead with a previous decision. You'd never complete a game.



The TMO never had a chance to tell the referee he'd made a huge mistake.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #154 on: »
Quote from: Mayor West on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 15:13*
The officials really messed up in the game yesterday. In many ways. Doesn’t change the result.



Actually, it probably would if you strike off the Lynagh try.
Logged
Disagree Disagree x 1 View List
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #155 on: »
Quote from: Marsile on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 17:18*


The TMO never had a chance to tell the referee he'd made a huge mistake.

As soon as he saw it he mentioned it to the ref. They had a conversation about it.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #156 on: »
Quote from: Marsile on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 17:18*


The TMO never had a chance to tell the referee he'd made a huge mistake.

You're getting the hang of this now. Much more subtle.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #157 on: »
Quote from: JammyGit on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 17:45*
As soon as he saw it he mentioned it to the ref. They had a conversation about it.



More homer refereeing. Blight on the game.
 
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #158 on: »
Quote from: Marsile on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 18:15*


More homer refereeing. Blight on the game.

Again, the ref was correct in his call that it was too late to reverse it. The TMO spotted it too late. It happens. But then absolutely no one expects you to be doing anything other than muck flinging on here.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #159 on: »
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #160 on: »
Yes, I'm sure that's the highlight of your long weekend.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #161 on: »
Hopefully the ref who incorrectly sent Fin Smith to the bin for playing the ball from an offside position despite no ruck having been formed will do the right thing and rescind sarries' try bonus point from Friday night.
Logged
Funny Funny x 3 Winner Winner x 1 View List
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #162 on: »
Quote from: RodneyRegis on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 19:15*
Hopefully the ref who incorrectly sent Fin Smith to the bin for playing the ball from an offside position despite no ruck having been formed will do the right thing and rescind sarries' try bonus point from Friday night.


Sure, no problem with that as long as the rule is consistently applied.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #163 on: »
Quote from: RodneyRegis on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 19:15*
Hopefully the ref who incorrectly sent Fin Smith to the bin for playing the ball from an offside position despite no ruck having been formed will do the right thing and rescind sarries' try bonus point from Friday night.

I haven't seen that incident but there can be an offside line at a tackle - you don't need a ruck.
Logged
Re: TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ
« Reply #164 on: »
Quote from: Brown Bottle on Sunday 31-Mar-2024, 23:32*
I haven't seen that incident but there can be an offside line at a tackle - you don't need a ruck.

OK, so you haven't seen it - but you thought you'd impart your knowledge anyway? Not like you :)

Have a watch. It's an interesting one. As far as I can see, the ball having left the tackle area removed the offside line, if indeed there even was a tackle or anyone over the ball - but I'm sure there are plenty with a more intricate understanding of the joke book we call the current laws.

World Rugby Passport - 14 Tackle
passport.world.rugby
Logged
Pages: 1 ... 9 10 [11] 12   Go Up
« previous next »
  3. TEAM v Bath Saturday 30th March.....#COYQ